Penname: cathrl [Contact] Real name: cathrl
Member Since: 04/29/2007
Membership status: Administrator
Bio:

Very long-time BotP fan (I remember the initial run on the BBC when I was nine). More newly a fan of Gatchaman, but far from an expert, and I've only seen the first series.

I'll beta-read anything rating-wise, but I'm not comfortable discussing explicit stuff. So, if it's a small part of your fic, that'll just be one part I won't comment on. If it's a big part of your fic, you're probably better off getting someone else to beta it. Happy with AUs, OCs etc. - but I will tell you if they don't work for me. Drop me an email if you're interested - but, I'll be honest, I'm not the beta for you if you're going to be upset by being told where I see weaknesses plot and character-wise. I do more than just proofread.

Really recommend you go into my fic by clicking on "Series" - because it does have a definite order, and it's sorted correctly in there.

 


[Report This]
Stories by cathrl [50] Reviews by cathrl [44] Series by cathrl [2] Challenges by cathrl [1] Fanart by cathrl Favorite Stories [1] Favorite Series [1] cathrl's Favorites [5]
 
Reviews by cathrl
Summary: Jason prepares his car for his next big race.

Originally written as part of the 2010 Christmas exchange in "Gatchmania," it was one of three prompts given to me by lborgia, for whom it was written. The prompt that inspired this story is as follows:

A pic of the Condor in his car (civvy mode or transformed) – any medium.
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: Jason
Genre: Character Study
Story Warnings: None
Timeframe: Mid-Series
Universe: Canon
Word count: 2161 - Read Count: 2960 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 06/01/2011 - Published: 05/31/2011
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed starstarstarstarhalf-star
Date: 06/01/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I enjoyed this a lot. I like the concept of Jason doing something physical (and useful) instead of meditation, and there are lots of nice little touches, such as Tiny and Keyop leaving wrappers in his car, and it not having as many seats to clean when transmuted. And that he thinks being picked up must be like flying...but actually he prefers driving.

Just a couple of little nitpicks - I don't get a clear  sense of the location. I feel like I want it to be somewhere out in the middle of nowhere, no houses, no people, but then there's this convenient water supply which makes it sound much less deserted.

And if he was practicing marksmanship he wouldn't be shooting at cans and bottles. For a bit of fun, sure. But they're simply far too big to be useful, serious practice for a crack shot.

But I'm nitpicking. This is excellently presented, technically flawless as far as I can see, and well paced.

Nice one.

Summary: G-Force is hacked off, and 1-Rover-1 may be a trademark infringement. What else can go wrong for Zark?
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: 7-Zark-7/1-Rover-1/Susan, Mark, Other Crossover Character
Genre: Humor/Comedy, Plot-What-Plot, Vignette
Story Warnings: Mild Language
Timeframe: Other
Universe: Tenuously Canon
Word count: 953 - Read Count: 2289 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 08/18/2011 - Published: 08/17/2011
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 08/28/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

(snigger), (snort), (splutter)

I wanna know what Jason says when he finds out...

Just brilliant.



Author's Response: Well, I doubt if Jason would say anything that could air on BotP! Thanks for the compliment.

Summary: While transporting an update for the Conway Tapes software to Riga, G-Force is attacked over a range called Traitor's Pass. Surrounded in his car by Spectra, Jason is captured. Anderson fears that the attack was staged, and Jason has defected...
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 20 - Table of Contents
Characters: Jason
Genre: Action/Adventure
Story Warnings: Mild Violence
Timeframe: Mid-Series
Universe: Canon
Word count: 15068 - Read Count: 80747 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 04/22/2012 - Published: 08/28/2011
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 09/29/2011 Title: Chapter 12: Chapter 12

This is fun and well-written (especially so since I think your first language isn't English?). I like that your characters are started to doubt one another and that the evidence entirely plausibly points to Jason.No snap judgements and random swings in character here, which is great.

But I am struggling with the very short chapters. I've just barely got back into the story and it's over, and there's another request to review. You're asking for reviews every 500 words. I find that's simply not long enough to form an opinion.

I promise you a full review when the story's finished...and I suspect this is why you're not getting many at the moment.



Author's Response: Hi cathrl! Thank you for the comments! You're right about the short chapters, I'm trying to change it, hence the longer gaps between updates :)

Summary: What compels some fanfic writers?
Categories: Gatchaman
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: Original Character, Sosai X
Genre: Essay, Humor/Comedy, Self-Insertion
Story Warnings: Drug References, Mild Language
Timeframe: Other
Universe: Tenuously Canon
Word count: 868 - Read Count: 2517 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 11/20/2011 - Published: 11/19/2011
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 11/29/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

I always think: if they went on to chapter 2, they liked it. Which doesn't help with a oneshot.

Interesting concept told in a fun way, and I especially liked the stealth wheelchair comment.

cath, who's also guilty of not reviewing half as often as she should.



Author's Response: You just gave me an idea: what if I label each paragraph as a chapter? (Okay, maybe only if I'm being REALLY obnoxious!) Still, I'm glad you enjoyed it.

Summary: A continuation of Daniella T's "A fic for a pic".
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: A Fic for a Pic series
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: Jason, Original Character
Genre: Humor/Comedy
Story Warnings: Adult Situations
Timeframe: Other
Universe: Alternate Universe
Word count: 807 - Read Count: 92 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 12/30/2011 - Published: 12/29/2011
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 12/30/2011 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Howling at the extra towers holding pictures, and "sketches of abstract stick figures" - I guess your artistic talent is somewhere near mine :)

Okay, where's chapter 2 - I want to know what the solution is...



Author's Response: Glad you liked it! I've been trying to improve my artistic ability - soon I'll be up to "pathetic". (Sad thing is, my mother was a painter who'd had several New York gallery showings in her day!)

Summary:

Sequel to "Life Starts Now" in my Raven series.  

Ken is still struggling with his decision during the Jigokillers. When things get ugly, and Galactor reveals a terrifying competence, he's determined not to make the same mistake twice. As a result, Joe is left behind to lead the team and figure out Ken's cryptic goodbye, while Ken is trapped in his own personal hell.

The next story in this series is "Never Too Late." 


Categories: Gatchaman
Series: Raven
Chapters: 18 - Table of Contents
Characters: Berg Katse, Dr. Kozaburou Nambu, Jinpei, Joe Asakura, Jun, Ken Washio, Kentaro/Red Impulse, Phoenix/God Phoenix, Ryu Nakanishi
Genre: None
Story Warnings: Adult Situations, Crude Humor, Death, Drug References, Drug Use, Erotica, Explicit Material, Graphic Violence, Mature Content, Sexual Dialogue, Sexual Situations, Slash, Strong Language, Suicide, Torture, Violence, Yaoi
Timeframe: Mid-Series
Universe: Tenuously Canon
Word count: 43150 - Read Count: 1799 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 03/04/2012 - Published: 03/04/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 06/14/2012 Title: Chapter 18: Epilogue

Oh.

My.

God.

That was absolutely fantastic.

I will now go have a howl.



Author's Response: LOL thanks so much :)

Summary: The Great War with Spectra is over and the G-Force team has moved on with their lives.  But Princess has a choice to make.  Should she return to the Commander she has always loved or stay with his second-in-command? 
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: The Heart Has Its Reasons ...
Chapters: 8 - Table of Contents
Characters: Chief Anderson, Jason, Keyop, Mark, Mary Sue, Other Canon Character, Princess, Tiny Harper
Genre: Angst, Hurt/Comfort, Romance
Story Warnings: Mild Language
Timeframe: Sequel
Universe: Alternate Universe
Word count: 7467 - Read Count: 28658 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 03/06/2012 - Published: 03/06/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 03/09/2012 Title: Chapter 8: Epilogue

I love this story! You've managed to simultaneously make Mark sympathetic while he's behaving like a complete and utter entitled jerk. It must be difficult for him. He's used to getting everything he wants, and to that being OK because what he wants is to protect other people. Now suddenly that isn't his motive so he's absolutely not entitled to get what he wants any more.

What Mark needs is someone who won't put up with any of this entitled BS and who has better things to do than wait around until he's ready to give her attention. Any chance of there being a female Red Ranger pilot out there...?

And poor old Jason, still hurting after all this time, and unable to even hit someone without doing himself major damage :(



Author's Response: Thanks for the review, Cath.  :)  This piece benefitted greatly from beta reading and Bird Scramble - Mark was a far less sympathetic character before.  I hope the reworked ending worked better for you.    

- Revelations by jublke - Rated: 8+ - - starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 5]
Table of Contents
Summary: Following implant surgery, Chief Anderson requires Jason to come clean and prove his honesty by providing details of exactly what went wrong with his implant and how it has impacted his health.  Reluctantly, Jason complies, but he is startled to discover another reason for the assignment …  Fourth in the Fall and Rise of the Condor series.
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: Fall and Rise of the Condor
Chapters: 4 - Table of Contents
Characters: Chief Anderson, Jason, Keyop, Mark, Princess, Tiny Harper
Genre: Angst, Drama, Hurt/Comfort
Story Warnings: Mild Language
Timeframe: Sequel
Universe: Alternate Universe
Word count: 9543 - Read Count: 11786 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 03/28/2012 - Published: 03/28/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 03/29/2012 Title: Chapter 4: Chapter 4

I don't normally review stories I've betaed, but I'm making an exception for this one. It has, without question the best "oh crap" plot twist in any fanfic I've ever read.

 And that's all I'm saying. I burnt dinner the first time I read this, I'd hate to spoil someone else's chance to do the same...



Author's Response: Aw, thanks, Cath!  I will always think of this as the fic that made Cath burn dinner.  It's the nicest compliment I've ever received about my fiction and it encouraged me to keep going with these stories.  :)

Summary: Jinpei wakes up in a strange place, where the team has drastically different lives ... all except for him. 
Categories: Gatchaman
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: Dr. Kozaburou Nambu, Jinpei, Joe Asakura, Jun, Ken Washio, Ryu Nakanishi
Genre: Vignette
Story Warnings: Mild Language, Mild Sexual References
Timeframe: Mid-Series
Universe: Canon
Word count: 2183 - Read Count: 3479 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 04/01/2012 - Published: 04/01/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 04/02/2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Great idea! Really creepy in places, and I love that they're called Ace and Dirk :)

Author's Response: As I agonized over character names, it suddenly hit me that those were perfectly cheesy. :)

- Love Always by jublke - Rated: 13+ - - starstarstarstarhalf-star [Reviews - 10]
Table of Contents
Summary: It's hard to be in love in the middle of a war ...
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: Chief Anderson, Jason, Keyop, Mark, Princess, Tiny Harper
Genre: Romance, Vignette
Story Warnings: Mild Adult Situations
Timeframe: Mid-Series
Universe: Alternate Universe
Word count: 704 - Read Count: 2793 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 04/13/2012 - Published: 04/13/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 04/16/2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Awww!!!

I saw it coming, but still... I love that it's not just a crush, it's a fait accompli.

And yes, Keyop will have a fit.



Author's Response: Yes, even if it doesn't last forever, she'll always be his first love.  :)

Summary: A BOTP origin fic. How Anderson found and selected Mark, Jason, Princess, Tiny, and Keyop, in preparation for making them the front line of the coming war against Spectra.
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 8 - Table of Contents
Characters: Chief Anderson, Colonel Cronus, Jason, Keyop, Mark, Princess, Tiny Harper
Genre: Drama, General
Story Warnings: Mild Language
Timeframe: Prequel
Universe: Mostly Canon
Word count: 26924 - Read Count: 25623 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 07/21/2012 - Published: 07/19/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 07/24/2012 Title: Chapter 8: Chapter 8

I LOVED this. Nice twist, having Mark not selected because of who he is, but really wanting to be. And not having him and Jason at daggers drawn all the time. And that's a very clever retcon having Keyop as older than he looks/is because he's not quite human. And I do like that you haven't gone for Anderson as single father of five - not that it's wrong, but it's good to see people do something different.

There's a followup, right? Where we learn why Isabelle isn't part of canon?

I only had one qualm and it's really minor and nitpicky - a lot of the scenes with four year old Mark sounded like a much younger child to me. There's a lot of carrying going on. I know he's had tragedy in his life, and I can buy handholding and hugs, but I don't know a four year old boy who'd be seen dead being carried.

Beautifully written, smooth, easy read, completely plausible different take on things. Loved it. Want more.



Author's Response:

Thanks. :) I saw that note on battleoftheplanets.net about Keyop not being a kid and the elfin alien thing, and I thought hmm, that really deserves to be used somewhere. I've got a few notes on possible follow-ups. One might be on what happened to Isabelle (I don't have that answer yet). Another might be on what causes Jason to get a bit bitter (I do have some ideas on that). 

For a bit I was going to have him a single father of five, but the more I thought about it, the more I thought well, these are kids and they're going to suddenly have super-powers, but they won't have self-control. At minimum his place would have gotten trashed. At worst, Mark in particular could have gotten seriously hurt or killed. I love to explore the ramifications of where technology and society intersect (and that's why I enjoy your work so much!)

When it comes to children, I don't have any (this gift exchange was an interesting one for this reason alone). Both of my betas do, and they did their best to straighten me out in a number of spots, but it's entirely possible that once they fixed the worst of it they didn't notice the rest. :) I'm pretty good at writing cute kids, but I'm better at it if I don't have to be specific on their ages, and writing kids in trauma and their reactions age-wise was definitely a learning experience. Nothing like asking a variety of friends awkward questions!

Summary: Keyop Anderson, the former Mighty Swallow of G-Force, goes for Olympic gold!
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: Jason, Keyop, Mark, Princess, Tiny Harper
Genre: Article, Vignette
Story Warnings: None
Timeframe: Sequel
Universe: Alternate Universe
Word count: 815 - Read Count: 3132 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 07/27/2012 - Published: 07/27/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 09/20/2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

How did I miss this? Loved it. And I agree, the whole "if you're chasing me, the real guy's being left in peace" line is probably the best redirection there is.

But...no implant, and coming out, and doing something that public, and he's made a lot of enemies...



Author's Response: Excellent point, cath!  I should have thought of that & addressed it in the story.  Hmm ... this one might require a follow-up.  For now, maybe Jason's tagging along for reasons other than just choreography ... ;)

- Stress Relief by jublke - Rated: Everyone - - starstarstarstarstar [Reviews - 5]
Table of Contents
Summary: When you work a stressful job for the Federation and you're always on call, what can you do to relax?
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: Jason, Mark
Genre: Humor/Comedy, Plot-What-Plot, Vignette
Story Warnings: None
Timeframe: Mid-Series
Universe: Tenuously Canon
Word count: 350 - Read Count: 1960 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 09/01/2012 - Published: 09/01/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 09/13/2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

My brain has now officially exploded.

I misread it first time and thought he was doing sheepdog trials, which was pretty bizarre, but not as bizarre as what he was really doing!

Howling with  laughter here.

Summary: If Galaxy Security ever needed to raise revenue through television advertisements, their ads might look something like this ...
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: 7-Zark-7/1-Rover-1/Susan, Chief Anderson
Genre: Humor/Comedy, Vignette
Story Warnings: None
Timeframe: Mid-Series
Universe: Canon
Word count: 291 - Read Count: 2781 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 10/04/2012 - Published: 10/04/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 10/05/2012 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Just don't sneeze...

(snigger)



Author's Response: LOL.  I didn't think of that, actually.  But then, I always picture Anderson as being in control of everything.  I should really write a fic sometime where he's in control of nothing.

Summary:

Vignettes as sequels to the fanfic Defiance, spun from the "Bradbury's Jar" challenges at Gatchamania.com. Two new chapters added


Categories: Gatchaman, Battle of the Planets
Series: The Disturbediverse
Chapters: 7 - Table of Contents
Characters: Devil Star/Galaxy Girl, Jason, Joe Asakura, Ken Washio, Mark
Genre: Character Study, Drama, Vignette
Story Warnings: Adult Situations
Timeframe: Sequel
Universe: Alternate Universe
Word count: 2861 - Read Count: 17262 - Completed: No
Updated: 08/29/2023 - Published: 12/13/2012
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 03/12/2013 Title: Chapter 5: The Beginning

Remarkably restrained of Jay...

...and what useful information did someone think they'd get from a psych eval of someone doped to the eyeballs?

Bets that the person in the chain of command who authorised it is unfindable?

Summary: In the years before there was Gatchaman, or the Science Ninja Team, Nambu called upon a team of men who would eventually become known as Red Impulse. These are their stories.

In the middle of a tense assignment, Washio is joined by his new team mates -- and becomes the target of a mysterious blonde woman.
Categories: Gatchaman
Series: None
Chapters: 2 - Table of Contents
Characters: Berg Katse, Dr. Kozaburou Nambu, Goon, Kentaro/Red Impulse, Original Character, Other Canon Character, Sosai X
Genre: Action/Adventure, Angst, Character Study, Drama, Mystery
Story Warnings: Adult Situations, Blood, Guts & Gore, Death, Graphic Violence, Mature Content, Mild Adult Situations, Mild Language, Mild Sexual References, Strong Language, Violence
Timeframe: Prequel
Universe: Tenuously Canon
Word count: 18804 - Read Count: 5266 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 05/27/2013 - Published: 05/27/2013
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 06/09/2013 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 2 -- The Outcomes

Oooh, I like this! Great writing technically, a lot of creepy uncertainty, and I especially like that you haven't made RI into a cuddly nice guy.

Summary: Galaxy Security thought Spectra was the worst of its worries. They were horribly wrong. A cross-over with TNT's Falling Skies.
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: None
Chapters: 8 - Table of Contents
Characters: Phoenix/God Phoenix
Genre: Action/Adventure, Angst, Drama, Horror, Hurt/Comfort, Romance, Tragedy
Story Warnings: Adult Situations, Death, Graphic Violence, Mature Content, Sexual Situations, Torture, Violence
Timeframe: Other
Universe: Cross-Over
Word count: 21741 - Read Count: 22891 - Completed: No
Updated: 02/07/2016 - Published: 07/22/2013
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 08/17/2013 Title: Chapter 3: Chapter 3

Liking this a lot. Falling Skies is definitely one of the creepier sci-fi shows out there at the moment.

"I know things we can't afford for those bastards to learn." Brrr.



Author's Response: Creepy is one way to describe it at times. This has been bouncing around in my head for a while. I'm glad you're enjoying it, Catherine.

Summary: While Ryu is vacationing with his family, fishing ships begin to disappear and the team is called in to find -- and fight -- an unseen enemy beneath the ocean waves.

Written during part of the Bradbury’s Jar on Gatchmania in 2012, the word prompts were: father, food, freedom, gift, journey, heat, foil, seconds, yearn, nemesis, expose, and unity
Categories: Gatchaman
Series: None
Chapters: 1 - Table of Contents
Characters: Berg Katse, Dr. Kozaburou Nambu, Jinpei, Joe Asakura, Jun, Ken Washio, Original Character, Other Canon Character, Phoenix/God Phoenix, Ryu Nakanishi, Sosai X
Genre: Action/Adventure, Character Study, Drama
Story Warnings: Death, Mild Violence
Timeframe: Mid-Series
Universe: Mostly Canon
Word count: 8038 - Read Count: 1748 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 10/04/2014 - Published: 09/28/2014
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: 11/12/2014 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

This is great! Very much in the spirit of the episodes, plausibly nasty pseudoscience, and great in-character interactions.

Much enjoyed.

Summary: About a month prior to the events of Attack of the Space Terrapin (BotP ep.1) Spectra and the Federation are gearing up for war. A young and untried G-Force team chafes at the bit, waiting for deployment.
Categories: Battle of the Planets
Series: Battle of the Planets: 2163
Chapters: 2 - Table of Contents
Characters: 7-Zark-7/1-Rover-1/Susan, Chief Anderson, Goon, Jason, Keyop, Mala/S-9, Mark, Original Character, Other Canon Character, Phoenix/God Phoenix, Princess, Tiny Harper, Zoltar
Genre: Action/Adventure, Character Study
Story Warnings: Adult Situations, Sexual Situations, Violence
Timeframe: Prequel
Universe: Alternate Universe, Tenuously Canon
Word count: 17874 - Read Count: 5848 - Completed: Yes
Updated: 12/10/2015 - Published: 12/10/2015
- [Report This] -
Reviewer: cathrl Signed
Date: 12/20/2015 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 2

Oh wow, a lovely early Christmas present!

Much enjoyed this. I like Al Jones a lot and this was a very plausible tale of how she gets involved with Anderson.

Loved Jason critiquing Tiny's piloting strategies and complaining about seatbelts (I guess they get fitted as a result of his complaints :). And Action Anderson. And, well all of it really!



Author's Response: Thanks for the review, Catherine. I don't know that seatbelts ever really did get fitted to the Phoenix. Maybe if JJ Abrams directs a reboot we'll get them (along with lens flare.)